19
Got told my nebula shots were too blue and it actually made me rethink everything
A guy at the Denver Astronomical Society meetup last month looked at my Orion Nebula photo and said "you know that's not what it actually looks like, right?" I was pretty defensive at first because I thought the blue was dramatic and cool. But then I went back and reprocessed the data with more realistic color balance and honestly the natural hydrogen-alpha reds look way better. Has anyone else had to totally redo their editing process after one comment from someone older in the hobby?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
thomas.river1mo ago
Read an article recently from a guy who processes data from the Hubble telescope, and he said even they make choices about color that aren't "real" but are supposed to show the science better. So there's this whole spectrum between looking natural and looking dramatic, and where you land on it is totally personal. That comment from the older guy about nebula shots being too blue is super common in the hobby, and yeah, those first attempts at processing usually end up looking like a neon cocktail. Bet your new version with the hydrogen-alpha reds popping through feels way more rewarding to look at too.
3
robin8961mo ago
That comment stings at first but it's usually a gift in disguise. The whole "false color vs true color" debate in astrophotography is really tricky. Some people go way overboard with the blues and it looks like a neon sign instead of space. Your new processing with the hydrogen-alpha reds showing through is probably much closer to what you'd actually see through a big dob. Glad you gave it another shot.
1