Had to choose between a coal forge and propane for my first setup in the garage

I was saving up for months and finally had $300 to spend, so I picked a propane forge because I figured it'd be cleaner for indoor use (no smoke in the house garage, you know?). First couple heats on a small knife blade went smooth, no major issues with temperature control. Anyone else start with one fuel type and wish they'd gone the other way?

3 comments

3 Comments

lilyt232d ago

So was the coal heat more forgiving for hammering out thick steel or just nostalgia talking?

colegarcia3d ago

Started with a charcoal forge in my driveway and switched to propane after a year. The propane was way easier to control for smaller pieces like knives and hooks, plus no smoke in my face. But I do miss the feel of working with coal especially for bigger projects like railroad spike stuff. If you're in a garage you made the right call though, propane keeps it simple and clean.

garcia.wren2d ago

@lilyt23 I think the nostalgia part is real but the coal heat does hold a little longer in thick metal. Still, propane is such a relief for your lungs and eyes.