Serious question, does anyone else think the slump test is overrated on small pours? | Concrete Finishers - Freelance Forum - The Community for Independent Professionals
Serious question, does anyone else think the slump test is overrated on small pours?
I did 14 basement slabs last summer in Fort Wayne and stopped doing slump tests on anything under 4 yards, and my callbacks for cracking went from 3 down to zero. The old timers around here act like skipping the cone is a sin, but watching the mud come off the chute tells me more than a number. Anyone else trust their eyes over the test on small jobs?
Doubt the cone is the reason your callbacks went away. Slump only tells you how wet the mix is, not whether the batch was off, so skipping it on 14 slabs and blaming zero cracks on that is a stretch. Plenty of things could've changed: your base prep, the weather, curing, who was on the crew. Watching mud come off the chute is fine for a gut check, but it won't catch a hot load or a bad air content, and those crack slabs too.