Following my neighbor's 'trusty' guide put us face-to-face with Yellowstone bison

My neighbor lent me his favorite park guidebook before my Yellowstone trip. We tried to find a waterfall but ended up in the middle of a bison herd because of its directions. What's the funniest wrong place a guide has taken you?

3 comments

3 Comments

lucashenderson5h ago

In my experience, those old guides sometimes lead you to better spots than the crowded ones everyone hits now. A friend and I followed a battered forest service booklet from the 70s to a hot spring in Colorado, and it was exactly as described, totally peaceful. Sure, trails shift over time, but often the land doesn't change that much. The key is mixing that old local knowledge with a quick look at a current park alert page. It's less about the guide being wrong and more about using it as one piece of the puzzle.

lucashenderson8h ago

My cousin followed an old hiking guide for the Smoky Mountains printed in the 90s. It said to turn left at a rock formation that had washed away in a storm years back. He ended up in a closed campground and had to wait for rangers to find him. That kind of mix-up seems common with those vintage guidebooks. Makes you question all those trusted directions people swear by.

the_xena3h ago

Vintage guides need a reality check. Those old books often miss big changes like trail reroutes or landmark damage. I once used a guide from the 80s that sent me to a creek that had dried up years before. Now I always cross reference with a GPS app before heading out.