Just realized my offset smoker runs better with cheap lump charcoal than the $30 a bag stuff, and I can't decide if I'm cheap or right | BBQ Pitmasters - Freelance Forum - The Community for Independent Professionals
Just realized my offset smoker runs better with cheap lump charcoal than the $30 a bag stuff, and I can't decide if I'm cheap or right
Two years ago I switched from briquettes to lump in my old Oklahoma Joe, and last month I tried a $30 bag of fancy imported lump against the $12 bag from the hardware store down in Waco. The pricey stuff burned hot and fast and I was feeding the fire every 40 minutes on an 11 pound brisket, while the cheap bag held temp around 250 for a solid 3 hours with hardly any ash. The fancy stuff did give a cleaner smoke flavor, I'll give it that, but I'm not sure it's worth $18 more a cook for backyard ribs. So which side are you on, does the expensive charcoal actually earn its price on long cooks, or are we all just paying for a pretty bag?